Challenges of a circular transition
1. Changing mindset and perceptions
Transitioning to a CE requires a mindset shift at all levels, from top leadership to consumers and suppliers. It demands a broader perspective that extends beyond waste management, and, for companies and governments, an understanding of regulations, taxation implications, standards and circular metrics.
2. Scaling-up
Although circular economy regulations are one of the fastest developing sustainability regulations in the world, the global circularity rate has actually declined from 9.1% in 2018 to 7.2% in 20237. This decrease highlights the ongoing challenges in raising awareness, scaling and generating demand, and building the capacity to implement circular models.
3. Economic and labour displacement vs just transition
The CE transition is a major economic shift, with significant impacts on industries and the labor market. If not managed well, this shift could displace sectors, small and medium enterprises and the workforce. Asia Pacific in particular also must engage the large informal sector to enable a just transition.
4. Costs of circular materials
Factors such as supply and demand dynamics, market volatility, and low economies of scale can drive up the cost of recycled materials. Although initial CE production costs may be higher, they can present substantial cost-saving opportunities in the medium to long term.
Enablers of the circular transition
1. Building awareness and communication
Raising awareness and educating key stakeholders—including leadership, customers, suppliers, policymakers and investors—on the impact and value of a circular economy is essential. Securing their buy-in, along with continuous engagement and feedback, is vital for refining processes and aligning CE products and services with future market needs.
2. Standards, incentives and sustainable financing
Transitioning to a mature CE requires a thorough ecosystem shift, necessitating common standards, policy support and sustainable financing to drive adoption of new CE business models. Organisations, along with policymakers and financial institutions, play a crucial role in setting these frameworks and providing the necessary support for a successful transition.
3. Designing and using technology and data
Products designed with CE principles require circular thinking to maximize resource lifecycles. Technology, especially AI, can enhance circularity by driving innovation in materials, automating design, maintenance, and recycling processes, and improving market efficiency through better supply-demand matching.
4. Collaboration, ecosystem thinking and integration
A successful transition to a mature CE requires a collaborative approach that embraces ecosystem thinking and integration. Understanding the complex interdependencies within and across organisations is essential to identify challenges and opportunities. Collaboration is needed across departments, with start-ups and technology firms, and through partnerships with suppliers, policymakers and financial institutions. This integrated approach aligns efforts throughout the value chain, enabling effective risk mitigation, value capture and value creation. By coordinating resources and fostering innovation, stakeholders can drive both individual and shared success, creating lasting value for the entire ecosystem.
5. Developing capabilities and supporting a just transition
The circular economy transition will unevenly impact sectors and jobs, particularly in extractive and manufacturing sectors. To minimise disruptions, it's crucial to equip workers (including informal workers) and micro-small and medium enterprises with necessary skills and resources. Collaboration between governments, industry and communities is essential to support these vulnerable groups.