Client Advisory Letter

July 2019

This is a publication about developments in Philippine taxation. The contents usually include latest Republic Acts, Bureau of Internal Revenue issuances, Customs regulations, Court decisions, BSP circulars, SEC circulars, Department of Justice opinions and Executive Orders relevant to Tax practice.

Talk to us

For further discussion on the contents of this issue of the Client Advisory Letter, please contact any of our partners.

Request for copies of text

You may ask for the full text of the Client Advisory Letter by writing our Tax Department, Isla Lipana & Co., 29th Floor, Philamlife Tower, 8767 Paseo de Roxas, 1226 Makati City, Philippines. T: +63 (2) 8845 2728. F: +63 (2) 8845 2806. 

Taxes, compliance matters, assessments, and refunds

Settlement of dues

Club membership fees, assessment dues are not subject to income tax and VAT

Membership fees and assessment dues collected by recreational clubs from their members as an inherent consequence of their membership and intended for the maintenance, preservation, and upkeep of the clubs’ general operations and facilities are not subject to income tax.

They are likewise not subject to VAT because in collecting such fees, the club is not selling its services to its members. Conversely, in paying such fees, the members are not purchasing services from the club.

(GR No. 228539, promulgated 26 June 2019)

Safe to assume

When proof of remittance of withholding taxes is not required

A taxpayer claiming a refund of or issuance of tax credit certificate for unutilized CWT is not required to prove actual remittance of CWT by withholding agents.

The taxpayer-claimant only needs to prove the fact of withholding by presenting the BIR Form No. 2307 which shows the income payments made by the withholding agent, and the amount of the tax deducted and withheld therefrom. Since the BIR Form No. 2307 is duly signed and prepared under the penalties of perjury, the figures appearing therein are presumed to be true and correct, and may be taken at face value.


(CTA EB No. 1789, promulgated 5 July 2019)

Beyond scope

The exercise of governmental functions are not subject to VAT

The sale of generating assets by the Power Sector Assets and Liabilities Management Corporation (PSALM) is not subject to VAT because such sale was made pursuant to the mandate of PSALM under the Republic Act No. 9136[1] to privatize assets of the National Power Corporation (NPC). In other words, the sale is not in pursuit of a commercial or economic activity, but a governmental function mandated by law.

Gross receipts from the lease of NPC assets, and collections of certain income and receivables are also not subject to VAT because these are within the powers of PSALM necessary to discharge its legal mandate and are undertaken in the exercise of governmental functions.

(GR No. 226556, promulgated 3 June 2019)

Unsafe to assume

Transfer of land for shares in a new corporation is not subject to VAT

A real estate company entered into a pre-incorporation subscription agreement. In consideration for its subscription of shares in the new corporation, the real estate company transferred two parcels of land instead of paying cash.

According to the CTA, the transfer of land is not a deemed sale transaction subject to VAT because, although the transferor was engaged in the real estate business, there was no proof or hint that the parcels of land were properties held for sale or originally intended for sale or for use in the ordinary course of business.

Further, since the transaction is in the nature of a pre-incorporation subscription pursuant to Sections 61 and 62 of the Corporation Code, the transfer is not a disposition or exchange in the ordinary course of trade or business subject to VAT.

(CTA EB No. 1776, promulgated 5 July 2019)

Square one

New documentary evidence may be submitted to the CTA

In deficiency tax assessments, the failure of the taxpayer to submit documents at the administrative (i.e., BIR) level is not fatal to the petition for review at the judicial (i.e., CTA) level because the case is litigated anew and decided based on what will be presented and formally offered by the parties during the trial.

(CTA EB No. 1881, promulgated 5 July 2019)

Irregular dealings

How to prove that a supplier is a non-regular supplier

A top ten thousand (10,000) private corporation is required to withhold a 2% EWT from its purchase of services from local/resident suppliers not otherwise covered by specific EWT rates.

However, one-time purchases below PHP10,000.00 from non-regular suppliers are not subject to deficiency 2% EWT, provided, that such fact is supported by the relevant Semestral Lists of Regular Suppliers.

(CTA Case No. 8141, promulgated 26 June 2019)

Exclusive club

Authority of OIC-Assistant Regional Director to sign and issue an LOA

Under the Tax Code and RMO No. 43-1990, only the Commissioner, Deputy Commissioners and Regional Directors are authorized to sign and issue LOAs. An OIC-Assistant Regional Director is not included.

Hence, a deficiency tax assessment arising from a tax investigation covered by a LOA that was signed and issued by an OIC-Assistant Regional Director without delegated authority is void.

The subsequent appointment of said OIC as a Regional Director does not cure the defect because the validity of the LOA should be reckoned from its date of issuance.

(CTA Case No. 9387, promulgated 28 June 2019)

Business trips

Documents supporting the deductibility of travel and transportation expenses

In order to be deductible, the taxpayer should establish that the expense was incurred in connection with its business.

Expenses for foreign travels can be proven to be business-related if the taxpayer is able to submit documents such as certificates of attendance to conferences abroad or copies of minutes of meetings held abroad.

On the other hand, transportation expenses can be proven as business-related if corroborated by expense reports accompanied by receipts, invoices, tickets, and a document indicating the kind of work completed by the employee and signed off by the taxpayer’s client.

(CTA Case No. 8141, promulgated 26 June 2019)

Dearly departed

Clarifying issues and concerns in the estate tax amnesty implementation

The BIR issued clarifications regarding the estate tax amnesty. These include the following:

  • The Estate Tax Amnesty Return (ETAR) should be filed within two (2) years from 15 June 2019 or until 14 June 2021.
  • The heirs, including minors, are required to have a TIN.
  • Where to file the ETAR
    • If the estate has a previously issued TIN, the ETAR shall be filed with the RDO which issued said TIN
    • For a non-resident decedent, the ETAR shall be filed with the RDO where the executor or administrator is registered. If the latter is not registered, the ETAR shall be filed with the RDO having jurisdiction over the legal residence of the executor of administrator. If there is no executor or administrator, the ETAR shall be filed with RDO No. 39.
    • If there are properties with multiple decedents emanating from the first decedent and no estate tax returns were filed, the ETAR for each stage of succession shall be filed with any of the RDOs having jurisdiction over the last residence of any of the decedents.
  • Filing and payment of the estate tax amnesty shall be done manually.
  • If there is no zonal valuation at the time of death, the fair market value appearing in the tax declaration issued at the date of death or the succeeding available tax declaration issued nearest to the date of death shall be used for valuation purposes.
  • When an estate tax return was previously filed and there were properties not declared therein, the estate tax amnesty shall be six percent (6%) of the value of undeclared properties without deductions, except for the share of the surviving spouse in the conjugal property.
  • The estate tax amnesty may be availed with respect to unpaid penalties provided the ETAR is filed and the minimum estate tax amnesty rate of PHP5,000.00 is paid.
  • Installment payment of the amnesty tax is not allowed.
  • With respect to real property involved in multiple successions, only one (1) eCAR will be issued if the ETARs are filed simultaneously with the same RDO.
  • Delinquent estate tax liabilities are covered by the tax amnesty on delinquencies.
  • Failure to submit the validated Acceptance Payment Form with proof of payment on or before 14 June 2021 is tantamount to non-availment of the estate tax amnesty.
  • If no death certificate is issued by the Philippine Statistics Authority (PSA), a Certificate of No Record of Death from the PSA and any valid secondary evidence including those issued by any government agency are sufficient to establish the fact of death.

(Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 68-2019, issued 5 July 2019)

New certificates

Availability of newly enhanced withholding tax certificates

The following enhanced BIR Forms are already available:

BIR Form No.

Description

2306

Certificate of Final Tax Withheld at Source

2307

Certificate of Creditable Tax Withheld at Source

(Revenue Memorandum Order No. 74-2019, issued 24 July 2019)

Bank notice

Availability of BIR Form Nos. 0620 and 0621

All concerned banks are informed that BIR Form No. 0620 (Monthly Remittance of Taxes Withheld on the Amount Withdrawn from the Decedent’s Deposit Account) and BIR Form No. 0621 (Quarterly Remittance of Taxes Withheld on the Amount Withdrawn from the Decedent’s Deposit Account) are not yet available in pre-printed form, in the eFPS and in the eBIRForms. However, these can be downloaded from the BIR website under BIR Forms-Payment/Remittance Form section.

Banks availing the Philippine Payment Settlement System are advised to manually file the above forms and remit the corresponding tax until further notice.

(Revenue Memorandum Order No. 76-2019, issued 31 July 2019)

Annual returns

Availability of newly revised annual information returns

All withholding agents are informed of the availability of the following revised BIR Forms (January 2018 ENCS):

BIR Form No.

Description

1604-C

Annual Information Return of Income Taxes Withheld on Compensation

1604-E

Annual Information Return of Creditable Income Taxes Withheld (Expanded)/ Income Payments Exempt from Withholding Tax

1604-F

Annual Information Return of Income Payments Subjected to Final Withholding Taxes

The revised manual returns are available in the BIR website under the BIR Forms-Payment/Remittance Forms section. However, they are not yet available in the eFPS and eBIRForms.

(Revenue Memorandum Order No. 73-2019, issued 24 July 2019)

Modes of extinguishment

Lifting of collection remedies exercised by the BIR

A Warrant of Garnishment, Notice of Tax Lien, Notice of Tax Levy and Notice of Encumbrance may be extinguished under any of the following instances:

  1. Full payment of unpaid tax liabilities, including applicable delinquency penalties
  2. Acceptance of full payment of taxpayer’s offer for compromise settlement
  3. Full payment of the basic tax due and subsequent approval of abatement of penalties by the CIR due on the subject tax liabilities
  4. Full or partial cancellation of the original assessment as a result of reinvestigation or reconsideration
  5. Prescription of BIR right to assess and/or collect
  6. The taxpayer has opened an escrow account with an AAB or has filed a surety bond
  7. Full destruction of the improvement of property subject to the lien due to fortuitous events
  8. Issuance of a final and executory court order for the lifting thereof
  9. The seized property was disposed and no longer owned by the delinquent taxpayer before the seizure, lien or encumbrance
  10. The account garnished is for the salaries of government employees
  11. Meritorious instances with prior approval by the CIR

However, the taxpayer should request for the issuance of a Notice of Lifting and comply with the procedure and requirements.

(Revenue Memorandum Order No. 41-2019, issued 31 July 2019)

Current form

Prescribing the newly revised BIR Form No. 1914 for tax refund/credit applications

Taxpayers applying for tax credits or refunds should accomplish and file the newly revised BIR Form No. 1914 (Application for Tax Credits/Refunds) April 2019 (ENCS).

(Revenue Memorandum Order No. 75-2019, issued 29 July 2019)

Service oriented

Procedures for serving assessment notices to taxpayers

The BIR prescribed guidelines and procedures when serving assessment notices such as the Preliminary Assessment Notice, Final Assessment Notice/Formal Letter of Demand and Final Decision on Disputed Assessment (FDDA).

The guidelines and procedures include the following:

  • Manner of effecting personal service, substituted service and service by mail
  • Substituted service can only be resorted to when the party is not present at the registered or known address.
  • Service by mail shall be done through registered mail, reputable professional courier service, or ordinary mail.
  • Personal or substituted service shall be effected by the Revenue Officer assigned to the case, or by any BIR employee duly authorized for such purpose.
  • Personal service is complete upon actual delivery of the assessment notice to the taxpayer or his representative.
  • Service through registered mail is complete upon actual receipt by the taxpayer or after five (5) days from the date of receipt of the first notice of the postmaster, whichever is earlier.
  • Service by ordinary mail is complete upon the expiration of ten (10) days after mailing.
  • Service to the tax agent/practitioner who is appointed or authorized by the taxpayer in accordance with existing revenue issuances shall be deemed service to the taxpayer.

(Revenue Memorandum Order No. 40-2019, issued 30 July 2019)

Model employees

Policies, guidelines and procedures on employee registration

The amended policies and guidelines on employee registration include the following:

  • Employers shall secure the TIN of new employees through eRegistration within ten (10) days from the date of employment.
  • Employees who subsequently move to a new employer shall transfer his/her TIN/registration to the RDO having jurisdiction over his/her place of residence and not to the RDO of the new employer.
  • Applications for any change in registration information of an employee shall be submitted by the employee to the RDO where the employee’s TIN is registered.
  • Only the employee himself/herself shall request and receive the TIN Card by presenting at least one (1) valid government ID upon application and release. TIN card requests should be made personally by the requesting employee.

(Revenue Memorandum Order No. 37-2019, issued 23 July 2019)

Certified exempt

Clarifying the nature, character and tax treatment of exempt organizations

The BIR clarified the nature, character and tax treatment of organizations exempt from income tax under Section 30 of the Tax Code. However, the clarifications do not cover the processing of CTEs of non-stock, non-profit educational institutions.

The clarifications include the following:

  • Characteristics, purposes and actual operations of each exempt organization
  • Organizational and operational tests in determining entitlement to exemption
    • The organizational test - The constitutive documents must show that the primary purpose of an organization falls under Section 30 of the Tax Code.
    • The operational test - The regular activities must be exclusively devoted Non-profit, inurement prohibition
  • Taxation of organizations under Section 30 of the Tax Code
  • Documentary requirements and procedure in the processing and issuance of CTEs
    • The request for CTE shall be filed with the Revenue District Office where the organization is registered.
    • The Regional Director is responsible for signing and issuing the CTE.
  • The CTE shall be valid for three (3) years from the effectivity date specified in the Ruling and may be revalidated for another 3 years.
  • The Tax Exemption Ruling shall be deemed revoked if there are material changes in the character, purpose or method of operation which are inconsistent with the basis for exemption.

(Revenue Memorandum Order No. 38-2019, issued 24 July 2019)

Swift and decisive

Civil remedies for the collection of accounts receivable/delinquent accounts

The BIR offices responsible for the enforcement of collection remedies shall immediately pursue the civil remedies for collection (e.g., issuance Warrant of Distraint and/or Levy) upon receipt of the “Form 40-Collectible” reports relative to the following:

  1. List of Unpaid Revenues – These are self-assessed taxes arising from dishonored check, unpaid second installment and duly validated unpaid tax due per returns.
  2. List of Unpaid Tax Assessments – These are tax assessments arising from tax investigations that have become final and executory.

Thus, Preliminary Collection Letters and Final Notices Before Seizure shall no longer be sent to delinquent taxpayers before collection remedies are pursued.

(Revenue Memorandum Order No. 35-2019, issued 18 July 2019)

Insurance matters

Modification of ATCs for certain percentage taxes

The following Alphanumeric Tax Codes (ATCs) for percentage taxes under RA No. 10001 have been modified:

Existing (per ATC Handbook)

New

ATC

Description

Tax Rate

BIR Form No.

Tax Rate

PT120

Life insurance premium

5%

2551M/

2551Q

2%

 

 

PT130

Agents of Foreign Insurance Companies

 

Insurance agents

 

 

10%

 

 

4%

(Revenue Memorandum Order No. 36-2019, issued 18 July 2019)

Lone delegate

Signatory of certificate of tax exemption for qualified retirement plans

The authority to act on and approve Qualified Reasonable Benefit Retirement Plans, and issue the appropriate CTE has been delegated to Assistant Commissioner Larry M. Barcelo, Legal Service.

(Revenue Delegation Authority Order No. 3-2019, dated 24 July 2019)

Refund status

Clarifying the transitory provisions and requirements for VAT refund claims

The BIR clarified the transitory provisions and requirements in Annex A.1 of RMC No. 47-2019 as follows:

  1. For VAT refund applications filed from 1 June to
    30 June 2019, the deadline for the submission of the following requirements was extended up to 31 July 2019:
    • Certification of VAT payment from the Revenue Accounting Division of the BOC;
    • Consularized/apostilled copy of certificate of foreign registration of the non-resident foreign corporation; and
    • Certifications required for claims whose zero-rated sales are based on Section 108(B)(4) of the Tax Code.
  2. For claims filed from the effectivity of RMC No. 47-2019, the following need not be authenticated by the BOC:
    • Import Entry and Internal Revenue Declarations and/or Single Administrative Document;
    • Statement of Settlement of Duties and Taxes; and
    • Commercial Invoices on importations.

(BIR Tax Advisory, dated 28 June 2019)

Following instructions

Non-acceptance of BIR Form Nos. 1901 and 1903

All Authorized Agent Banks (AABs) are advised not to accept the following BIR Forms:

  • BIR Form No. 1901 – January 2018 ENCS (Application for Registration of Self-Employed and Mixed Income Individuals, Estates/Trusts), and
  • BIR Form No. 1903 – January 2018 ENCS (Application for Registration of Corporations/Partnership, Taxable/Non-Taxable), including GAIs, LGUs, Cooperatives and Associations in the payment of business registration fee.

Taxpayers should use the BIR Form No. 0605 (Payment Form) in the business registration fee made thru AABs.

In encoding payments using BIR Form No. 0605 in the Limited Bank Data Entry System, AABs should select BIR Form 0605 in the Form Code List of Values (LOVs) and select the appropriate tax type code LOVs as indicated in the BIR Form No. 0605 under the tax type field.

 (Bank Bulletin No. 2019-13, dated 17 June 2019)

Contact us

Lois Ann Caroline Sarajan

Lois Ann Caroline Sarajan

Tax Assistant Manager, PwC Philippines

Tel: +63 (2) 8845 2728

Lyn Golez-Geronan

Lyn Golez-Geronan

Tax Librarian, PwC Philippines

Tel: +63 (2) 8845 2728