Client Advisory Letter

August 2020

This is a publication about developments in Philippine taxation. The contents usually include latest Republic Acts, Bureau of Internal Revenue issuances, Customs regulations, Court decisions, BSP circulars, SEC circulars, Department of Justice opinions and Executive Orders relevant to Tax practice.

Talk to us

For further discussion on the contents of this issue of the Client Advisory Letter, please contact any of our partners.

Request for copies of text

You may ask for the full text of the Client Advisory Letter by writing our Tax Department, Isla Lipana & Co., 29th Floor, Philamlife Tower, 8767 Paseo de Roxas, 1226 Makati City, Philippines. T: +63 (2) 8845 2728. F: +63 (2) 8845 2806.

Taxes, compliance matters, assessments, and refunds

Secondary purpose

Taxability of foreign exchange gains derived by a PEZA-registered enterprise

In 2007, a business process outsourcing company registered with the Philippine Economic Zone Authority (PEZA) as an Ecozone IT (Export) Enterprise under the income tax holiday (ITH) regime derived foreign exchange (forex) gains from its hedging contract with a bank.

Through the hedging contract, the company used its earned United States Dollars (USD) to purchase Philippine Pesos (“Pesos”) on pre-determined dates and exchange rates in order to pay local business expenses.

After the declaring the forex gains in its income tax return and paying income tax thereon, the company filed a claim for refund of said income taxes. According to the company, since its PEZA-registered activity is the establishment of a contact center, forex gains derived under the hedging contract which is related to the contact center is covered by the ITH. Further, the activity that led to the forex gain involved the sale of USD earned through the contact center and the purchase of Pesos needed to pay operational expenses.

The Court of Tax Appeals (CTA) denied the claim because even though the earned USD was being used to purchase Pesos for purposes of paying the company’s ordinary and necessary expenses, the fact still remained that the forex gains were derived from the hedging contract with the bank and not from the registered activity as a contact center.

However, the Supreme Court (SC) reversed the CTA decision. The SC granted the claim for refund and ruled that hedging is considered very much related to the registered activity of the company, hence, is also subject to the ITH. It pointed out that the secondary purpose in the company’s Articles of Incorporation authorizes the latter to enter into a hedging contract to protect against devaluation in terms of local currency.

(GR No. 216601, promulgated 7 October 2019)

Needless appraisal

Determining the fair market value of shares sold, exchanged or bartered

For capital gains tax purposes, the Secretary of Finance has discarded the use of the Adjusted Net Asset Method (which adjusts assets and liabilities to fair market values) in determining the fair market value (FMV) of unlisted shares sold, exchange or bartered.

The new rules in determining the FMV of shares are as follows:

Shares

Prima facie FMV or FMV

Common shares

Book value based on the latest available financial statements (AFS) duly certified by an independent public accountant prior to the date of sale, but not earlier than the immediately preceding taxable year

Preferred shares

Liquidation value - which is equal to the redemption price of the preferred shares as of balance sheet date nearest to the transaction date, including any premium and cumulative preferred dividends in arrears

Common shares (when there are also preferred shares)

Book value computed by deducting the liquidation value of the preferred shares from the total equity of the corporation and then dividing the result by the number of outstanding common shares as of balance sheet date nearest to the transaction date

Significantly, the book value of common shares or the liquidation value of the preferred shares of stock does not anymore need to be adjusted to include any appraisal surplus from any property of the corporation not reflected or included in the latest AFS. In other words, the latest AFS shall be sufficient in determining the FMV of the shares.

(Revenue Regulations No. 20-2020, published 19 August 2020)

Equality in taxation

Implementing tax parity between Islamic and conventional banking transactions

Republic Act No. 11439 entitled “An Act Providing for the Regulation and Organization of Islamic Banks” mandates neutral tax treatment between Islamic and equivalent conventional banking transactions. Pursuant to this mandate, the Secretary of Finance issued implementing regulations which provide for the following:

  • Islamic banking transactions must have parity of tax treatment, such that Islamic banking transactions are taxed no more heavily and no more lightly than conventional banking transactions.
  • Where an Islamic banking arrangement is economically equivalent to a conventional bank product, the tax treatment should be the same.
  • Any reference to interest shall apply to gains or profits received and expenses incurred in Islamic banking arrangements, in lieu of interest income and/or expenses under the conventional banking transactions.
  • Any reference to a disposal or lease of an asset shall not apply to any disposal or lease of an asset by or to a person that is carried out in accordance with Islamic banking arrangements as defined by the Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas.
  • Islamic banks shall ensure that financial statements are prepared in accordance with the Philippine Financial Reporting Standards taking into account the differences between Islamic and conventional banking transactions.
  • Authorized conventional banks with Islamic banking arrangements shall maintain a system segregating the transactions of the Islamic banking unit from its conventional banking business
  • Authorized Islamic banks shall register with the BIR similar to conventional banks following existing guidelines. Islamic banks, including conventional banks with Islamic banking windows, shall issue receipts on profits, gains and fees derived from banking operations.

(Revenue Regulations No. 17-2020, published 8 August 2020)

Temporary establishment

Tax issues regarding the prolonged stay of alien individuals

The BIR issued the following guidelines and requirements to address unplanned tax implications and burdens with respect to alien employees of foreign corporations whose stay in the Philippines was prolonged as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic:

  1. With respect to alien employees covered by tax treaties to which the Philippines is a signatory, employment income will not be subject to Philippine taxation if:
    1. The employee has not been present in the Philippines for more than 183 days (more than 120 days for residents of Poland and at least 90 days for residents of the United States of America) in aggregate in the year of income, fiscal year, calendar year or any 12-month period, depending on the applicable tax treaty;
    2. The remuneration is paid to the employee by or on behalf of an employer that is not a resident of the Philippines; and
    3. The remuneration is not deductible against the profits of a permanent establishment (PE) which the foreign employer has in the Philippines.
  2. The Philippines may tax employment income of alien employees covered by tax treaties to which the Philippines is a signatory if:
    1. The employee is in the Philippines for more than 183 days (more than 120 days for residents of Poland and at least 90 days for residents of the United States of America);
    2. The employer is a resident of the Philippines; or
    3. The non-resident employer has a PE in the Philippines which bears the remuneration.
  3. Where an alien individual is prevented from leaving the Philippines on his or her scheduled departure date as a result of travel restrictions imposed as a COVID-19 safety measure, the individual resident will not be regarded as being present in the Philippines for tax residence purposes after the scheduled departure date.
  4. A work-from-home arrangement between a foreign company and its employees in the Philippines due to compliance with quarantine measures would not create a PE on the part of the foreign company because the arrangement lacks a certain degree of permanency and the home office is not at the disposal of the foreign company.
  5. Temporary interruptions of construction activities due to the COVID-19 pandemic should be included in computing the duration of a construction site and in determining if the same constitutes a PE.
  6. Where an employee, partner or agent of a non-resident foreign corporation (NRFC) continues to be present in the Philippines as a result of COVID-19 travel restrictions, the BIR shall disregard such presence for income tax purposes with respect to said NRFC if:
    1. The NRFC did not have a PE before the effects of COVID-19;
    2. There are no other changes in the NRFC’s circumstances except for the extended stay of the employee, partner or agent in the Philippines due to travel restrictions; and
    3. The employee, partner or agent should leave the Philippines as soon as circumstances permit.
  7. In order to prove that the extended presence was due to COVID-19 travel restrictions, the concerned individual or company shall submit to the BIR the:
    1. Authenticated sworn certification stating the relevant facts and circumstances of the bona fide presence of the employee in the Philippines;
    2. Duly executed contract;
    3. Certified true copies (CTCs) of the confirmed booking or flight itinerary for the original flight and for the re-booked flight;
    4. CTC of the travel advisory on the flight cancellation issued by the airline company;
    5. CTC of the boarding pass and employee’s passport, including blank pages; and
    6. Other documents that the BIR shall deem necessary.

(Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 83-2020, issued 17 August 2020)

eAFS expansion

Using the eAFS System in submitting other ITR attachments

The eAFS System is now available not only for the submission of attachments to the 2019 annual income tax return (ITR) but also for the submission of:

  1. Attachments to annual ITRs with fiscal year accounting period; and
  2. Attachments to quarterly ITRs.
  3. All taxpayers availing the facilities of the eAFS System, whether or not registered under the Large Taxpayers Service, shall scan the required documents and comply with the following procedures:
    • For the submission of attachments to the annual ITR, the following categories and file naming conventions shall be observed:

Document group and file name

Manually filed

Electronically filed

File 1

EAFS[TIN]ITRTYMMYYY

 

• ITR

• Proof of payment

 

 

  • ITR
  • Filing Reference Number (FRN) / Email confirmation
  • Proof of payment / Acknowledgment receipt

 

File 2

  • EAFS[TIN]AFSTYMMYYYY
  • AFS (Audited Financial Statement) composed of the following:
  • Certificate of Independent CPA, if applicable
  • Account Information Form and Financial Statements
  • Statement of Management’s Responsibility for ITR

 

File 3

  • EAFS[TIN]OTHTYMMYYYY-01
  • BIR Form No. 2304
  • BIR Form No. 2307
  • Tax debit memo, if applicable
  • BIR Form No. 1606
  • Proof of prior year’s excess credits, if applicable
  • Proof of foreign tax credits, if applicable
  • For amended ITR, proof of tax payment and previous ITR
  • Report of electronically submitted Summary Alphalist of Withholding Tax at Source (SAWT), if applicable
  • Proof of other tax payments / credit, if applicable
  • BIR Form No. 2316
  • Others

 

  • For the submission of attachments to the quarterly ITR, the following documents shall be scanned and classified:

Document group and file name

Manually filed

Electronically filed

File 1

EAFS[TIN]ITR#QMMYYY

Quarterly ITR (BIR Form No. 1701Q or 1702Q

Filing Reference Number / Email confirmation

File 3

EAFS[TIN]OTH#QMMYYYY-01

 

File size should not exceed 4.8GB

 

In case of additional file:

 

File 4

EAFS[TIN] OTH#QMMYYYY-02

 

Where “#” is the Taxable Quarter

  • Emailed confirmation receipt of SAWT in the eSubmission Facility
  • BIR Form No. 2307
  • Tax debit memo
  • Others

 

Notwithstanding the electronic submission, taxpayers must keep the original copies in accordance with Section 203 of the Tax Code for the period prescribed under Revenue Regulations No. 17-2013.

(Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 82-2020, issued 11 August 2020)

Payment options

Manner of paying taxes during the MECQ from 4 August to 18 August 2020

In light of the Modified Enhanced Community Quarantine (MECQ) in the NCR, Bulacan, Cavite, Laguna and Rizal from 4 August to 18 August, taxpayers under the jurisdiction of Revenue District Office (RDO) Nos. 24 to 34 and 38 to 57 have the following tax filing/payment options:

  1. Tax returns may be filed with and taxes paid at the nearest authorized agent banks (AABs), regardless of RDO jurisdiction.
  2. Tax returns may be filed with and taxes paid to Revenue Collection Officers (RCOs) of the nearest RDO, even in areas where there are AABs.

    Cash payments should not exceed PHP20,000 while check payments have no limitation if made to the RCO in the district office. All check payments should be made payable to the Bureau of Internal Revenue. The name and branch of the receiving AAB may no longer be indicated therein.
  3. Electronic Filing and Payment System (eFPS) taxpayers shall continue to file through the eFPS and settle the tax liabilities with the AABs where they are enrolled. On the other hand, those filing tax returns via the eBIRForms facility may pay taxes through:
    1. Land Bank of the Philippines (LBP) Link.biz Portal (for taxpayers who have ATM accounts with LBP and/or holders of BancNet ATM/Debit/Prepaid Card, and taxpayers utilizing PesoNet facility (depositors of RCBC and Robinsons Bank))
    2. Development Bank of the Philippines Pay Tax Online (for holders of Visa/Mastercard Credit Card and/or BancNet ATM/Debit Card)
    3. Union Bank Online Web and Mobile Payment Facility (for taxpayers who have accounts with Union Bank of the Philippines)
    4. Mobile payment (GCash/PayMaya)

Accordingly, AABs are mandated to:

  1. Accept all tax payments from taxpayers registered under RDO Nos. 24 to 57, even out-of-district returns;
  2. Accept over-the-counter tax filings and payments by eFPS filers who encountered problems in paying through eFPS; and
  3. Accept check payments from any taxpayer even without the name of the receiving AAB branch indicated in the check, provided, that all check payments shall be made payable to the Bureau of Internal Revenue.
  4. The foregoing is effective until the MECQ is lifted and when the above areas have been placed under General Community Quarantine (GCQ).
  5. Note: President Rodrigo Duterte placed NCR, Bulacan, Cavite, Laguna and Rizal under GCQ starting 19 August 2020.

(Revenue Memorandum Circular Nos. 80-2020 and 79-2020, issued 6 and 5 August 2020; and Bank Bulletin Nos. 12-2020 and 11-2020, dated 6 and 5 August 2020)

Taxing Cebu

Manner of paying taxes in Metro Cebu during the MECQ

In light of the Modified Enhanced Community Quarantine (MECQ) in Metro Cebu, taxpayers under the jurisdiction of Revenue Region No. 13 – Cebu City have the following tax filing/payment options:

  1. Tax returns may be filed with and taxes paid at the nearest authorized agent banks (AABs).
  2. Tax returns may be filed with and taxes paid to the nearest Revenue Collection Officers authorized by the Revenue District Office.
  3. Tax returns may be filed with and taxes paid via the eBIRForms facility may pay taxes through:
    1. Land Bank of the Philippines (LBP) Link.biz Portal (for taxpayers who have ATM accounts with LBP and/or holders of BancNet ATM/Debit/Prepaid Card, and taxpayers utilizing PesoNet facility (depositors of RCBC and Robinsons Bank))
    2. Development Bank of the Philippines Pay Tax Online (for holders of Visa/Mastercard Credit Card and/or BancNet ATM/Debit Card)
    3. Union Bank Online Web and Mobile Payment Facility (for taxpayers who have accounts with Union Bank of the Philippines)
    4. Mobile payment (GCash/PayMaya)

The foregoing is effective until the MECQ is lifted and when Metro Cebu has been placed under General Community Quarantine (GCQ).

(Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 78-2020, issued 30 July 2020)

Issues in Makati

Requesting all AABs under RR No. 8A to accept tax filings and payments

In light of problems encountered by taxpayers within the jurisdiction of Revenue Region (RR) No. 8A, all authorized agent banks (AABs) under RR No. 8A are requested to accept all tax returns/payments of taxpayers from Revenue District Office Nos. 47 – East Makati, 48 – West Makati, 49 – North Makati and 50 – South Makati.

(Bank Bulletin No. 10-2020, 10 July issued 2020)

Contact us

Lois Ann Caroline Sarajan

Lois Ann Caroline Sarajan

Tax Assistant Manager, PwC Philippines

Tel: +63 (2) 8845 2728

Lyn Golez-Geronan

Lyn Golez-Geronan

Tax Librarian, PwC Philippines

Tel: +63 (2) 8845 2728