Client Advisory Letter

May 2020

This is a publication about developments in Philippine taxation. The contents usually include latest Republic Acts, Bureau of Internal Revenue issuances, Customs regulations, Court decisions, BSP circulars, SEC circulars, Department of Justice opinions and Executive Orders relevant to Tax practice.

Talk to us

For further discussion on the contents of this issue of the Client Advisory Letter, please contact any of our partners.

Request for copies of text

You may ask for the full text of the Client Advisory Letter by writing our Tax Department, Isla Lipana & Co., 29th Floor, Philamlife Tower, 8767 Paseo de Roxas, 1226 Makati City, Philippines. T: +63 (2) 8845 2728. F: +63 (2) 8845 2806.

IASB issues IFRS 16 COVID-19 rent concessions amendment

At a glance

As a result of the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic, rent concessions have been granted to lessees. Such concessions might take a variety of forms, including payment holidays and deferral of lease payments.
On 28 May 2020, the IASB published an amendment to IFRS 16 that provides an optional practical expedient for lessees from assessing whether a rent concession related to COVID-19 is a lease modification. Lessees can elect to account for such rent concessions in the same way as they would if they were not lease modifications. In many cases, this will result in accounting for the concession as variable lease payments in the period(s) in which the event or condition that triggers the reduced payment occurs.

What is the issue?

Rent concessions have been, or are expected to be, provided to lessees as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic. Such concessions might take a variety of forms, including payment holidays and deferral of lease payments for a period of time, sometimes followed by increased rent payments in future periods. IFRS 16 contains requirements that apply to such rent concessions. The IASB has noted, however, that applying those requirements to a potentially large volume of rent concessions related to COVID-19 could be complex – particularly in the light of the many other challenges that stakeholders face during the pandemic.

As a result, the IASB has provided lessees (but not lessors) with relief in the form of an optional exemption from assessing whether a rent concession related to COVID-19 is a lease modification. Lessees can elect to account for rent concessions in the same way as they would if they were not lease modifications. In many cases, this will result in accounting for the concession as a variable lease payment.

The practical expedient only applies to rent concessions occurring as a direct consequence of the COVID-19 pandemic and only if all of the following conditions are met:

  • the change in lease payments results in revised consideration for the lease that is substantially the same as, or less than, the consideration for the lease immediately preceding the change;
  • any reduction in lease payments affects only payments due on or before 30 June 2021; and
  • there is no substantive change to other terms and conditions of the lease.

Lessees that apply the exemption will need to disclose that fact, as well as the amount recognised in profit or loss arising from COVID-19-related rent concessions. If a lessee chooses to apply the practical expedient to a lease, it would apply the practical expedient consistently to all lease contracts with similar characteristics and in similar circumstances. The amendment is to be applied retrospectively in accordance with IAS 8, but lessees are not required to restate prior period figures or to provide the disclosure under paragraph 28(f) of IAS 8.

What is the impact and for whom?

Given the pervasiveness of the pandemic and the measures taken by many governments on social distancing, it is likely that many lessees will have been granted a rent concession of some form, and so these amendments would be applicable. The amendments, however, do not make any changes to lessor accounting.

When does it apply?

The amendments are mandatory for annual reporting periods beginning on or after 1 June 2020. Earlier application is permitted, including in interim or year-end financial statements not yet authorized for issue at
28 May 2020, to permit application of the relief as soon as possible, subject to any endorsement process.

Alternative proof

Registration payment forms constitute evidence of VAT registration

One of the requisites of a claim for refund of unutilized input VAT is that the taxpayer-claimant must be VAT-registered. Although the CTA denied the admission of the taxpayer’s BIR Certificate of Registration (for failure to present the original), the CTA ruled that the BIR Registration Payment Forms, standing alone, may be considered as evidence of VAT registration. It reasoned that since such forms are to the effect that what are being paid are annual VAT registration fees, the same will not be paid if the payor is not a VAT-registered person.

(CTA Case No. 9722, promulgated 12 March 2020)

Compromising position

When compromise penalty amount differs from that prescribed in RMO No. 19-2007

Under Revenue Memorandum (RMO) No. 19-2007, revenue officers are generally required to apply the amounts in the Revised Schedule of Penalties (“Schedule”) in Annex “A” thereof. The compromise penalty amounts can differ from those specified in the Schedule but only when duly approved by the BIR.

In this relation, the BIR may accept a compromise offer for a different amount provided that:

  1. When the compromise offer is lower than the prescribed amount, the approval of the CIR or concerned Deputy Commissioner/ Assistant Commissioner/ Regional Director is required; and
  2. When the compromise offer is higher than the prescribed amount, the offer must be in writing and if there is an Apprehension Slip, the form provided in Annex “B” of RMO No. 19-2007 shall be used.

All compromise offers must be in writing either in the form of Annex “B” of RMO No. 19-2007 or, if not applicable, the compromise agreement regarding penalties must be signed by both the taxpayer and the CIR or concerned Deputy Commissioner/ Assistant Commissioner/ Regional Director.

Therefore, without a written offer from the taxpayer, the imposition of compromise penalties should be in accordance with Annex “A” of RMO No. 19-2007. Accordingly, any amount paid in excess of the prescribed compromise penalties may be sought for refund.

Note: RMO No. 19-2007 was updated by RMO No. 7-2015 (Revised Consolidated Schedule of Compromise Penalties) which omitted the guideline providing for Annex “B” of RMO No. 19-2007 in cases where Apprehension Slips were issued.

(CTA EB No. 1947, promulgated 9 March 2020)

Upstream merger

The transfer of assets in an upstream merger is not subject to donor’s tax

In a merger between a parent company and its wholly-owned subsidiary (with the parent as the surviving company), the Commissioner of Internal Revenue ruled that the transfer of assets from the absorbed company to the surviving company is subject to donor’s tax.

However, the ruling was overruled by the Department of Finance (DOF) upon appeal. According to the DOF, said transfer of assets from a subsidiary to its parent company is not subject to donor’s tax for the following reasons:

  • there is no consideration of gratuity because there is no intention to perform an act of liberality on the part of the absorbed company; and
  • the transfer of assets from a wholly-owned subsidiary to its parent company, having the effect of a taxable liquidation, negates the position that it is a donation.

(DOF Opinion No. 12-2018, dated 27 November 2018)

Tax deadlines

Amendments regarding the extended due dates for tax filings and payments

The BIR further amended Revenue Regulations (RR) No. 10-2020 (as amended by RR No. 11-2020) as follows:

  • The term “quarantine” shall mean any announcement by the National Government resulting in limited operations and mobility, including, but not limited to, community quarantine, enhanced community quarantine and modified enhanced community quarantine.
  • Section 3 of RR No. 10-2020 (as amended by RR No. 11-2020) has been repealed. This means that regardless of another quarantine extension or modification, the defined extended due dates under Section 2 of RR No. 10-2020 (as amended by RR No. 11-2020) shall remain effect and shall not be further extended.
  • Taxpayers who filed tax returns before the extended due dates may amend and pay additional taxes any time on or before the extended due dates without incurring corresponding penalties. On the other hand, tax overpayments resulting from amended tax returns may be carried forward as tax credits against the same tax type or may be applied for refund.

(Revenue Regulations No. 12-2020, published 22 May 2020)

Sporting chance

Statutory sales discount in favor of National Athletes and Coaches

The BIR has promulgated the implementing rules and regulations (IRR) for the tax privileges granted by Section 4 of Republic Act No. 10699 to business establishments giving sales discounts and incentives to National Athletes and Coaches.

The IRR provides for the following, among others:

  • Business establishments shall grant sales discounts and incentives only to qualified National Athletes and Coaches who present Philippine National Sports Team Identification Cards (PNSTM IDs) and Booklets.
  • The sales discount shall be twenty percent (20%) of the sales amount exclusive of VAT with respect to the following:
    • Transportation services such as domestic air and sea transportation, and national land transportation
    • Hotel resorts and other similar lodging establishments
    • Restaurants
    • Recreation centers
    • Medicine and drug purchases
    • Sports equipment purchase
    • Admission fees in places of amusement
  • Manner of computing the sales discount
  • Subject to the following conditions, business establishments may deduct the sales discounts from gross income for income tax purposes:
    • The deduction should be claimed for the same taxable year that the sales discount was granted, and the names of the National Athletes or Coaches and corresponding PNSTM ID Numbers should be reflected in the record of sales.
    • For VAT taxpayers, the total amount of the claimed deduction (net of VAT) shall be included in gross receipts for VAT purposes.  For percentage tax taxpayers, the sales discount shall be included in the tax base for computing the percentage tax.
    • Only sales discounts on gross sales exclusively used, consumed or enjoyed by the National Athlete or Coach shall be deductible.
    • The gross selling price and the sales discount should be separately indicated in the official receipt or sales invoice.
    • If the business establishment availed of the OSD or the eight percent (8%) income tax rate, the sales discount cannot be claimed as a deduction from gross income.
    • Affected business establishments are required to keep separate and accurate records of sales which should include the name of National Athletes and/or Coaches, their PNSTM ID Numbers, gross sales/receipts, sales discount amounts, transaction dates and invoice number.
  • The sales discount cannot be claimed if the National Athlete or Coach claims a higher promotional discount as may be granted by the business establishment or laws, or in combination with other discount programs. Hence, National Athletes and Coaches who are also Senior Citizens or Persons With Disability can only claim a single 20% discount.

(Revenue Regulations No. 13-2020, published 29 May 2020)

Spontaneous conversion

Automatic conversion of unutilized tax credit certificates

The Secretary of Finance amended Revenue Regulations (RR) No. 5-2000 which governs the manner of issuing tax credit certificates (TCCs) and the conditions for their use, revalidation and transfer.

The amendment provides that any TCC, which remains unutilized after more than one year, shall be converted into cash without prior written notice from the BIR, subject to the availability of funds.

TCCs already expired upon the effectivity of RR No. 14-2020 shall be automatically cancelled by the BIR except those which are already with the BIR for purposes of utilization thru Tax Debit Memo, or conversion or revalidation.

The list of expired TCCs shall be circularized/posted in the BIR website within thirty (30) days from the effectivity of RR No. 14-2020. This shall be deemed as sufficient notice to the TCC owners.

(Revenue Regulations No. 14-2020, published 29 May 2020)

Payment facility

Online payment of taxes through PayMaya

The electronic/online payment of taxes can now be made through the PayMaya mobile application. Taxpayers opting to pay via PayMaya should follow these steps:

  1. Download the PayMaya App from Google Play Store, Apple App Store or Huawei AppGallery;
  2. Log into the created PayMaya account and click on the “Pay Bills” button;
  3. Enter all pertinent details for tax payment;
  4. Review transaction details before clicking on the “Pay” button; and
  5. Receive payment details via SMS and electronic mail (email).

For more information on how to avail the PayMaya tax payment facility, taxpayers may visit www.PayMaya.com, send an email to support@paymaya.com or call the hotline
+632 8845 7788.

(Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 54-2020, issued 28 May 2020)

Delinquente

Withdrawal of protest against FAN/FLD and appeals of FDDAs via email

For purposes of availing the tax amnesty on delinquencies, taxpayers are temporarily allowed to file via electronic mail (email) the withdrawals of their protests against Final Assessment Notices/Formal Letters of Demand (FANs/FLDs), or appeals of Final Decisions on Disputed Assessment (FDDA).

The guidelines for the online filing of withdrawals include the following:

  1. The letter-withdrawal must be in Portable Document Format (PDF) attached to the email and signed by the taxpayer or duly authorized representative. The PDF copy shall contain a scanned copy of the first page of the protest or appeal sought to be withdrawn bearing the BIR stamp of receipt and marked as Annex “A”.
  2. The subject and body of the email must be in accordance with the prescribed format in RMC No. 52-2020 and addressed to the appropriate BIR office.
  3. The withdrawal shall be deemed to have been filed on the date and time of receipt of the email.
  4. The regular physical filing of papers or pleadings in connection with protests or appeals shall resume when the ECQ or GCQ is lifted in which event the email filing of withdrawals shall no longer be allowed.

(Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 52-2020, issued 27 May 2020)

Overlooking jurisdiction

Where to file returns and pay taxes until 14 June 2020

In light of the extension of the ECQ and the implementation of the MECQ in some areas, the BIR extended until 14 June 2020 the leniency in the filing and payment of taxes per RMC No. 43-2020, thus:

  1. Tax returns may be filed with and taxes may be paid at the nearest AABs, regardless of RDO jurisdiction; and
  2. Tax returns may be filed with and taxes may be paid to Revenue Collection Officers (RCOs) of the nearest RDO, regardless of whether or not there are AABs.

For payments to RCOs, cash payments should not exceed PHP20,000 while check payments have no limit as to amount and should be made payable to the Bureau of Internal Revenue. The name of the receiving AAB branch may no longer be indicated.

Amnesty tax payments are also covered by the above extended leniency.

(Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 48-2020 issued 22 May 2020)

Stamp of receipt

Submission and stamping of filed 2019 ITRs and required attachments

Taxpayers have the following options in the submission of their filed 2019 income tax returns (ITRs) and required attachments:

  1. Through the nearest Revenue Collection Officers (RCOs), regardless of RDO jurisdiction
    1. For 2019 ITRs with payments made via the online payment facilities of AABs, the RCO shall stamp “RECEIVED” the ITRs and the pages of the Balance Sheet, Income Statement and Audit Certificate, if applicable.

      In the case of corporations and other juridical persons, at least two (2) extra copies of the audited financial statements (AFS) for filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission should be stamped “RECEIVED”.
    2.  For ITRs filed electronically, the RCO shall accept and stamp “RECEIVED”:
      1. only the print-out of the Filing Reference Number (FRN) generated from the eFPS/email confirmation from the eBIRForms System; and
      2. the pages of the Balance Sheet, Income Statement and Audit Certificate, if applicable.
  2. Out-of-district returns and attachments shall be forwarded by RCOs to the concerned RDOs.
    • Through the online eAFS
    • The eAFS system may be accessed at www.bir.gov.ph.
    • The required attachments shall be grouped into three (3) document files wherein the documents must be scanned and saved in PDF and named accordingly before uploading to the eAFS, as follows:

Document group and file name

Manually filed

Electronically filed

File 1

EAFS[TIN]ITR2019

ü  ITR

ü  Proof of payment

ü  ITR

ü  FRN / Email confirmation

ü  Proof of payment / Acknowledgment receipt

File 2

EAFS[TIN]AFS2019

AFS (Audited Financial Statement) composed of the following:

ü  Certificate of Independent CPA, if applicable

ü  Account Information Form and Financial Statements

ü  Statement of Management’s Responsibility for ITR

File 3

EAFS[TIN]OTH2019-01

 

File size should not exceed 4.8GB

 

File 4 (if necessary)

EAFS[TIN]OTH2019-02

ü  BIR Form No. 2304

ü  BIR Form No. 2307

ü  Tax debit memo, if applicable

ü  BIR Form No. 1606

ü  Proof of prior year’s excess credits, if applicable

ü  Proof of foreign tax credits, if applicable

ü  For amended ITR, proof of tax payment and previous ITR

ü  Report of electronically submitted SAWT, if applicable

ü  Proof of other tax payments / credit, if applicable

ü  BIR Form No. 2316

ü  Others

  • The eAFS will acknowledge submission by issuing a system-generated Transaction Reference Number (TRN) and by sending an email to the system user. The TRN shall serve as proof of submission in lieu of the manual “RECEIVED” stamping. However, the taxpayer must keep the original copies of the digitally submitted documents.

(Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 49-2020, issued 22 May 2020)

Game ready

Resumption of operations of POGO licensees and service providers

The BIR has issued guidelines, documentary requirements and conditions for the BIR clearance applications of Philippine Offshore Gaming Operator (POGO) licensees and service providers intending to resume operations.

Said guidelines, documentary requirements and conditions are detailed in Annex “A” of Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 46-2020 which may be accessed at or downloaded from www.bir.gov.ph.

(Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 46-2020, issued 7 May 2020)

Devolving power

Delegation of authority to sign certificate of tax exemptions/rulings for energy-related projects

In compliance with Republic Act No. 11234, otherwise known as the “Energy Virtual One-Stop Shop Act”, the Commissioner of Internal Revenue delegated the authority to sign Certificates of Tax Exemptions/Rulings on energy-related projects to the Assistant Commissioner, Legal Service.

(Revenue Delegation Authority No. 2-2020, issued 18 May 2020)

Bank instructions

Accepting tax payments for returns due within the community quarantine period

All AABs shall accept payment for tax returns mentioned in Section 2 of Revenue Regulations No. 11-2020 until the extended due dates of filing/payment without imposition of corresponding penalties. 

In this relation, AABs are reminded of the following responsibilities in the acceptance of the 2019 annual income tax return (ITR) and other tax returns, and the corresponding tax payments:

  • Accept all tax payments including out-of-district tax returns
  • Accept all tax payments where the taxpayer uses any of the following:
    • Official BIR Forms and copies of system-generated Filing Reference Numbers
    • Photocopies of returns/computer-generated or electronically-filed tax returns
    • Downloaded BIR Forms originally filled out and signed by the taxpayer or duly authorized representative
  • Receive the tax returns by stamping the official receiving seal on three (3) copies of the tax return whether or not the taxpayer is under the jurisdiction of a regional office with Document Processing Division
  • Copies in excess of three shall not be stamped “RECEIVED” by the AAB. Accordingly, in the case of juridical persons filing BIR Form No. 1702, the stamping of “RECEIVED” shall be extended to least two (2) additional copies of the audited financial statements, aside from those AFS attached to the ITRs.
  • In the payment of a single tax liability/return, accept payments through:
    • Checks;
    • Combination of cash and checks; or
    • Combination of two or more checks.
  • AABs should accept checks which are prepared payable to the Bureau of Internal Revenue, with or without “lFO Name and TIN of the taxpayer” written on the check payment as previously required.
  • Stamp “RECEIVED” the attached financial statements to the ITRs only on the page of the Balance Sheet, Income Statement and Audit Certificate
  • Accept tax payments from taxpayers who are already within the bank's premises by the close of the AAB’s banking hours
  • Accept check payments even after the bank cut-off/clearing time and just stamp the tax return “Received after cut-off/clearing" or with similar stamp
  • Accept the payment of manually filed and out-of-district returns from taxpayers enrolled in the eFPS in case of unavailability of the eFPS facility as announced by the BIR
  • Do not impose penalties for any violations committed by the taxpayers in the filing of tax returns and payments of taxes

(Bank Bulletin No. 5-2020, dated 20 May 2020)

Contact us

Lois Ann Caroline Sarajan

Lois Ann Caroline Sarajan

Tax Assistant Manager, PwC Philippines

Tel: +63 (2) 8845 2728

Lyn Golez-Geronan

Lyn Golez-Geronan

Tax Librarian, PwC Philippines

Tel: +63 (2) 8845 2728