Wage and apprenticeship guidance issued for energy bonus credits

December 2022

In brief

The Inflation Reduction Act of 2022 (IRA) created, extended, and expanded many tax credits to encourage production of clean energy, reduce carbon emissions, and promote domestic manufacturing. Many of the credits provide for a base rate, for example a percentage of the cost of constructing an asset or a dollar amount per unit of production, and increase the base rate for compliance with certain social policy-related requirements (bonus credits). The most significant and prevalent bonus credit provision is an increase of five times the base rate if the taxpayer meets certain prevailing wage and apprenticeship requirements.  

Taxpayers that begin construction of a relevant facility before the expiration of 60 days after Treasury issues guidance on the wage and apprenticeship requirements (60-day period end date) may be able to claim the wage and apprenticeship bonus credit although they do not meet the requirements. The IRS and Treasury have released Notice 2022-61, which provides preliminary guidance on the application of the wage and apprenticeship requirements. Notice 2022-61 states that it qualifies as guidance that starts the 60-day period, which ends on January 30, 2023.   

For consideration: Some project developers may find it advantageous to begin construction on IRA-eligible projects before the end of January to avoid uncertainty about compliance with these requirements. When beginning early construction is not feasible, companies should consider whether they may need a determination from the Department of Labor (DOL) of the prevailing wage rates that would apply to their projects and consider requesting that guidance as soon as possible.

In detail

Background

The wage and apprenticeship rules are detailed in the Section 45 production tax credit and generally adopted by cross-reference in other credit provisions. Section 45 provides a base credit of 0.3 cents (indexed for inflation) per kilowatt hour of electricity produced from qualified energy resources at a qualified facility and sold to an unrelated party during the 10-year period after the facility is placed in service. A facility placed in service after 2021 is a qualified facility, and the base credit is multiplied by five, if either the facility’s net output is less than one megawatt, construction begins before the 60-day period end date, or the taxpayer complies with the wage and apprenticeship requirements.

Prevailing wage requirement

Under Section 45, to meet the prevailing wage requirements, laborers and mechanics employed by a taxpayer, contractor, or subcontractor in constructing a qualified facility, or altering or repairing a qualified facility during the 10-year period beginning from the date the facility is placed in service or an alteration or repair occurs, must be paid wages at rates not less than those prevailing for similar work in that location, as most recently determined by the DOL. 

A taxpayer is deemed to satisfy the prevailing wage requirement, although not paying the prevailing wage rates, if the taxpayer (1) pays laborers and mechanics the difference between the prevailing wage rates and the amount actually paid plus interest and (2) pays a penalty of $5,000 times the number of underpaid workers. However, if the taxpayer intentionally disregards the requirements, the taxpayer must pay the workers three times the amount of the underpayment and pay a $10,000 penalty, to be deemed to have paid prevailing wages.

Apprenticeship requirement

A taxpayer may satisfy the apprenticeship requirements if no fewer than an applicable percentage of total labor hours of qualified facility construction, alteration, or repair work conducted by the taxpayer, a contractor, or a subcontractor is performed by qualified apprentices (labor hours requirement). The applicable percentages are 10% if construction begins before 2023, 12.5% if construction begins in 2023, and 15% if construction begins after 2023. These percentages may be modified as a result of DOL or state apprenticeship program requirements. If four or more workers are employed, at least one must be a qualified apprentice (participation requirement).

“Labor hours'' means (1) the total hours of construction, alteration, or repair work (2) performed by an individual employed by the taxpayer, contractor, or subcontractor, and (3) excluding foremen, supervisors, owners, and executive/administrative/professional employees. A “qualified apprentice” is an individual employed by the taxpayer, contractor, or subcontractor and participating in an apprenticeship program registered under and meeting the standards of certain labor laws.

A taxpayer is treated as satisfying the apprenticeship requirements (and may be able to claim the bonus credit) if the taxpayer has made a good faith effort to comply by requesting apprentices from a registered program that has (1) denied the request, unless the denial is the result of the taxpayer’s or contractor’s intentional disregard of the standards or requirements of the program, or (2) failed to respond within five business days. Alternatively, the taxpayer may pay a penalty of $50 ($500 for intentional disregard of labor hours and participation requirements) times the number of noncompliant labor hours.  

Other credits

The other credits and one deduction that have incorporated by reference the Section 45 wage and apprenticeship requirements in constructing, altering, or repairing a qualified facility generally are Section 30C (alternative fuel vehicle refueling property), Section 45L (energy efficient homes), Section 45Q (carbon capture and sequestration), Section 45U (zero emission nuclear power production), Section 45V (clean hydrogen production), Section 45Y (clean electricity production), Section 45Z (clean fuel production), Section 48 (investment in energy property), Section 48C (investment in advanced energy projects), Section 48E (investment in clean electricity generation), and Section 179D (energy efficient commercial building deduction). 

Generally, the base rate for each of these provisions is multiplied by five if the wage and apprenticeship requirements are met. Sections 45L and 45U require compliance with only the wage requirements to qualify for the bonus credit. The exception for construction beginning before the 60-day end date does not apply to the credits under Sections 45L, 45U, 45Z, or 48C, and applies only to small facilities under Section 48E.

Guidance

Notice 2022-61 provides preliminary guidance on the wage and apprenticeship requirements, including when construction of a facility and the installation of property begins, pending the anticipated issuance of proposed regulations. The notice “affects” facilities for which construction begins, and property for which installation begins, on or after January 30, 2023.

Notice 2022-61 provides the following guidance on these issues.

Prevailing wage requirements

A taxpayer and the taxpayer’s contractors and subcontractors must pay prevailing wages to mechanics and laborers employed in constructing, altering, or repairing a facility, property, project, or equipment. The taxpayer must maintain sufficient records, in accordance with the general recordkeeping requirements of Section 6001 and the related regulations, that establish compliance.

A determination of prevailing wages for a geographic area, type of construction, and labor classifications that DOL has published on www.sam.gov constitutes the prevailing wages for purposes of the prevailing wage requirement. If a labor classification is not listed, a taxpayer may provide certain information and propose labor classifications and prevailing wage rates to DOL via email and may rely on the resulting DOL determination. 

The prevailing rate for apprentices may be less than the prevailing rate for journeyworkers of the same classification. The prevailing wage rate for installing property for purposes of the Section 179D deduction is determined by reference to the prevailing wage rate for construction, alteration, or repair of a similar character in the locality where the property is located.

Apprenticeship requirements 

To satisfy the apprenticeship requirements, a taxpayer must:

(1)   Satisfy the apprenticeship labor hour requirement, subject to apprenticeship ratio requirements,

(2)   Satisfy the participation requirement, and

(3)   Maintain books and records, potentially including records for contractors or subcontractors, in accordance with Section 6001 and the related regulations, sufficient to establish compliance with these requirements.

A taxpayer will be considered to make a good faith effort in requesting qualified apprentices if the taxpayer requests qualified apprentices from a registered apprenticeship program in accordance with usual and customary business practices for registered apprenticeship programs in a particular industry. The taxpayer must maintain adequate records of its request and an apprenticeship program’s denial of, or failure to respond to, the request.

Definitions

The following definitions apply for purposes of the prevailing wage and apprenticeship requirements.

  • An individual is employed if the individual performs services in exchange for remuneration, regardless of whether the individual would be characterized as an employee or an independent contractor for other federal tax purposes. 
  • “Wages” is defined under 29 CFR 5.2(p) and includes bona fide fringe benefits.
  • “Laborer or mechanic’’ is defined under 29 CFR 5.2(m).
  • ‘‘Construction, alteration, or repair’’ is defined under 29 CFR 5.2(j).
  • The prevailing wage is the wage listed for a particular classification of laborer or mechanic in DOL’s wage determination for the type of construction and the geographic area, or as DOL otherwise determines. 
  • A prevailing wage determination is one issued by DOL.
  • An “apprentice-to-journeyworker ratio’’ means the ratio described under 29 CFR 29.5(b)(7).
  • ‘‘State apprenticeship agency” is defined under 29 CFR 29.2.

Beginning of construction or installation 

Notice 2022-61 describes previous guidance addressing when construction begins for purposes of particular credits: Notice 2013-29, clarified, modified, and updated by subsequent notices (Section 45); Notice 2020-12 (Section 45Q); and Notice 2018-59, modified and clarified by subsequent notices (Section 48). Notice 2022-61 applies some of the methods and safe harbors authorized in these earlier notices to determine whether construction of a facility or installation of property begins before the 60-day period end date, which would allow a taxpayer to claim a bonus credit without complying with the wage and apprenticeship requirements.

Notice 2022-61 provides that principles similar to the physical work test and 5% safe harbor under Notice 2013-29, the continuity requirement under each earlier notice, and the continuity safe harbor under Notice 2016-31, apply for purposes of Sections 30C, 45V, 45Y, and 48E. A taxpayer may rely on the continuity safe harbor if a facility is placed in service no more than four calendar years after the calendar year when construction began.

Installation of property is deemed to have begun for purposes of Section 179D if a taxpayer generally satisfies principles similar to the physical work test or the 5% safe harbor for determining the beginning of construction.  

Under the physical work test, construction of a facility begins when physical work of a significant nature begins and the taxpayer maintains a continuous program of construction. This test is based on the nature of the work and not costs and has no minimum thresholds. Preliminary activities such as planning or designing a facility, obtaining financing, conducting exploration or surveys, or obtaining licenses or work permits do not qualify as significant physical work even if included in the property’s depreciable basis. Work another person performs for the taxpayer  under a written binding contract may be taken into account.

The 5% safe harbor treats construction of a facility as having begun if a taxpayer pays or incurs 5% or more of the total cost of a facility and thereafter makes continuous efforts to complete the facility. All costs properly included in the depreciable basis of the facility are taken into account under the safe harbor. Costs incurred by a person that has entered into a written binding contract with a taxpayer to manufacture, construct, or produce property for the taxpayer are deemed incurred by the taxpayer.

The continuity requirement is that, for purposes of either the physical work test or the 5% safe harbor, a taxpayer must demonstrate either continuous construction or continuous efforts. Whether a taxpayer meets this requirement is determined by the relevant facts and circumstances. Under the continuity safe harbor, a taxpayer is deemed to satisfy the continuity requirement if a qualified facility is placed in service no more than four calendar years for purposes of Section 45 or Section 48, or six calendar years for Section 45Q, after the calendar year when construction of the qualified facility began.

Our Prevailing Wage and Apprenticeship (PWA) Compliance Services

Complying with PWA requirements drives the difference between a 30% and 6% credit - is your company capitalizing on the increased credit opportunity? Our specialists can provide in-depth education on the rules, establish highly effective compliance programs, and leverage cutting-edge technology to streamline the entire process.

Learn more

Contact us

Ed Geils

Ed Geils

Global and US Tax Knowledge Management Leader, PwC US

Follow us