Insurance: US Deals 2024 midyear outlook

While macroeconomic factors caused deal volume to slow, insurance dealmaking remained active in the last 6 months, driven by 4 announced megadeals.

For the six-month period from mid-November 2023 through April 2024, there was steady activity in the insurance deals market relative to other sectors despite a decrease in insurance deal volume. Lower deal volume resulted from a slight cooling in insurance brokerage deal activity because of interest rate uncertainty.

In this period, there were 145 announced insurance transactions with over $34 billion in announced deal value. This represents a decrease in deal volume but an increase in deal value compared to 318 announced insurance transactions and $11.2 billion in deal value from mid-May 2023 through mid-November 2023.

Highlights include four announced insurance megadeals. Aon plc’s acquisition of NFP Corp. for $13.6 billion, announced on April 25, was the largest. The acquisition expands Aon’s footprint in the middle-market segment, adding P&C brokerage, benefits consulting, wealth management and retirement advisory capabilities. Additionally, in April, Arch Insurance North America agreed to acquire Allianz’s US MidCorp and Entertainment insurance businesses for $1.4 billion, which expands Arch’s presence in the middle market and includes select specialty insurance programs. The deal is expected to close in the second half of 2024.


The primary trends we’ve seen include:

  • Interest rate uncertainty has impacted the insurance brokerage deal market. The relatively high cost of borrowing has changed the return profile of brokerage targets and slowed deal activity while buyers wait on the direction of the interest rate environment. Conversely, a high interest rate environment benefits carriers, who rely on spread income generated on investment portfolios to increase overall profitability.
  • Private equity (PE) has growing interest in support service providers for insurance distribution, including third-party administrators (TPAs) for claims, fronting carriers, and membership model aggregators. Given longstanding deal activity in insurance distribution, the expansion into support service providers allows buyers to expand their footprint in the market.
  • In the life and annuities (L&A) market, dealmaking has shifted from large acquisitions to an increase in reinsurance via alternative transaction structures. These include reinsurance into sidecars, which are largely funded by third-party capital. (Reinsurance transactions are generally excluded from the results in the chart to the right.)

Note: The primary M&A data source used in the midyear outlook is S&P Capital IQ.

How market conditions are impacting M&A strategy

The recent economic environment has generally been favorable to the insurance industry. Significant premium rate increases across P&C lines, coupled with higher spread on investments, have led to healthy profits. However, higher carrier profitability comes with rising valuations, which in some instances have led to downward pressure on M&A activity.

Of note, carriers continue to prioritize specialization, resulting in their outsourcing of underwriting niche risks to managing general agents (MGAs.) This has given the specialized MGA market a significant growth opportunity and acted as a catalyst for deals. We expect MGA deals will continue to increase, led by private equity-backed consolidators seeking underwriting expertise in products with significant growth potential. Importantly, market participants also will be able to create a more comprehensive insurance model. As a result, we anticipate correlated demand for insurance service providers such as TPAs and fronting carriers. 

What’s now?

A few current trends appear to be gaining steam:

  • Given sustained interest in the L&A market, there is strong desire for reciprocal and sidecar reinsurance arrangements. Sidecars allow:
    • Insurers to cede a portion of an in-force book of business and/or flow reinsurance of new business to third-party investors (generally hedge funds and private equity firms)
    • Third-party investor participation in insurance risk/returns by providing capital without a typical acquisition structure of a legal entity
    • For insurers, this increases available capital and allows for risk diversification.
  • After extensive investment in the last decade, we expect increased interest in US carriers from Asian markets. Note in May, AIG announced its sale of 20% of Corebridge to Nippon Life for $3.8 billion.
  • Deals have been impacted by the Bermuda Monetary Authority’s ongoing assessment of Bermuda’s regulatory framework, including changes to capital requirements. There is uncertainty about the impacts of the regulatory changes for L&A insurance companies domiciled in Bermuda or those redomiciling to different jurisdictions. 

What’s next?

Over the coming months, there are a few things insurance dealmakers should keep an eye on:

  • Continued consolidation of the life and annuity sector. We expect continued L&A sector consolidation, led by PE-backed buyers with access to alternative investment strategies. With a scaled portfolio of permanent capital assets, PE-backed buyers can generate higher investment yields on assets for policyholders and earn additional fees from carriers through unique sourcing and origination of private credit and alternative investment solutions. 
  • Potential reemergence of the IPO market: Companies are preparing for potential IPOs or evaluating dual track processes for exits, evaluating potential sales or public offerings.
  • Potential reemergence of P&C deal activity: There haven’t been many P&C deals over the last few years relative to L&A, but record profits in Q1 could change this state of affairs. P&C insurers are benefiting from a strong rate environment, with easing inflation driving down loss ratios and contributing to profitability.

“The insurance industry has earned record profits over the last year. Investors have taken note by deploying more capital to the insurance sector.”

— Mark Friedman, US Insurance Deal Leader

The bottom line

Thanks to higher investment yields and higher premiums, the insurance industry has recently outperformed most other sectors. Accordingly, there’s been steady activity in the insurance deals market, which shows no signs of slowing. In particular, as insurers focus on specialization and consolidators seek to create a more comprehensive insurance model, we anticipate ongoing demand for service providers such as TPAs and fronting carriers.

Explore national M&A trends

Follow us

Required fields are marked with an asterisk(*)

By submitting your email address, you acknowledge that you have read the Privacy Statement and that you consent to our processing data in accordance with the Privacy Statement (including international transfers). If you change your mind at any time about wishing to receive the information from us, you can send us an email message using the Contact Us page.

Hide