European Commission has issued a transfer pricing directive proposal
European Commission has issued a transfer pricing directive proposal which integrates key transfer pricing principles into the EU law with the aim of putting forward certain common approaches for Member States.
The rationale of the proposal derives from the fact that almost all Member States are also members of the OECD and therefore committed to follow the OECD principles and recommendations. However, despite the political commitment by the majority of Member States, the status and role of the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines currently differs from Member State to Member State.
For example, domestic legislation of Member States shows differences in the definition of ‘associated enterprises’ and in particular, on the notion of ‘control’ which is normally the precondition to apply transfer pricing. Certain Member States apply a threshold of 25% while others apply a threshold of 50% shareholding when it comes to determining whether the control criterion is met. It translates into businesses facing tax uncertainty, high compliance costs as well as frequent, time-consuming legal disputes leading, amongst others, to considerable amounts of legal fees and creating barriers to cross-border operations and high risks of double and/or over-taxation.
The proposal aims at simplifying tax rules through increasing tax certainty for businesses in the EU, thereby reducing the risk of litigation and double taxation and the corresponding compliance costs and thus improve competitiveness and efficiency of the single market. The proposal would provide a gradual development of common and consistent approaches among Member States’ tax authorities to the interpretation and application of transfer pricing rules through the incorporation of the arm’s length principle into Union law and the clarification of the role and status of the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines. Furthermore, the prospect for establishing common binding rules for Member States on specific transactions within the framework of the OECD Transfer Pricing Guidelines should improve businesses’ resilience in the Union, reduce distortions and contribute towards a level playing field in the single market.