In the context of Transfer Pricing, the purpose of a benchmarking study is to identify whether the tested related party transactions comply with the arm's length principle by identifying and using sources of comparable information about companies, prices and margins. In this short read we discuss what are the main considerations when conducting a benchmarking study and what are the main challenges.
Introduction
In the context of Transfer Pricing, the purpose of a benchmarking study is to identify whether the tested related party transactions comply with the arm's length principle by identifying and using sources of comparable information about companies, prices and margins.
What are the main considerations that one has to consider when conducting a benchmarking study?
Benchmarking studies involve identifying transactions that are comparable to the intercompany transactions in question. This includes looking at similar products or services, market conditions and business functions. By comparing these transactions, companies can determine a range of acceptable prices that align with the arm's length price.
To conduct a benchmarking study, companies often use commercial databases that contain information on transactions between unrelated parties. These databases provide a wealth of market data that can be used to find comparable transactions. The use of reliable and comprehensive data sources ensures that the benchmarking analysis is robust and defensible.
Transfer pricing regulations often require extensive documentation to support the prices charged in intercompany transactions. Benchmarking studies provide the necessary evidence and analysis as part of the documentation requirements.
Benchmarking studies help ensure that transfer pricing practices are consistent across different jurisdictions, reducing the risk of double taxation and disputes with tax authorities.
In the event of a tax audit, benchmarking studies provide evidence that the prices being charged are in line with market rates. This can significantly reduce the risk of adjustments and penalties imposed by tax authorities.
What are the main challenges faced when conducting a benchmarking study?
Nonetheless, benchmark studies can also be challenging due to several reasons:
The process of identifying comparable transactions or entities can be complex and time-consuming.
The selection criteria needs to be carefully defined to ensure that the comparables are truly similar in terms of functions, risks, and assets.
There may be limited availability of reliable data on uncontrolled transactions that are comparable to the controlled transaction.
Making comparability adjustments where appropriate can be difficult.
Benchmarking studies provide a systematic approach to determining arm's length prices, supported by detailed economic analysis and market data. The above challenges highlight the importance of a well-planned and executed benchmarking study in the context of transfer pricing.
How can we help?
Our team is here to support your organisation in preparing benchmarking studies for transfer pricing purposes. We tailor our services to your specific needs, offering preparation or review of transfer pricing documentation in accordance with the Maltese Transfer Pricing Rules.
Contact us
